Deputy Spruce said the plans represented a conflict between the search for a new golf course and the need to retain land for agriculture.
He said: "We feel it's essential agricultural land... is protected."
Deputy Spruce said: "To move another 150-odd acres of land from agriculture or dairy farming over to a golf course is just a step too far."
However, the plans have been supported by Deputy Ivan Rihoy.
He said: "Environmentally it would make the area fantastic. Golf courses are really environmentally friendly."
Deputy Spruce's amendment, seconded by Deputy Sillars, suggests preserving La Ramee exclusively for agriculture.
It will be put to the States in the November meeting as part of a debate on the government's strategic land use plan.
Guernsey currently has two 18-hole golf courses, situated at L'Ancresse and La Grande Mare, as well as a smaller course at the St Pierre Park hotel.
21 November 2011 Last updated at 11:44 GMT